DELHI PRESS
Two Years Late, the Quad Meets Tuesday on Borrowed Ground — Washington Says It Was Never on Life Support
The Quad’s leaders will meet in Manila on Tuesday evening for their first summit since 2024 — in a country that is not a member, because the chair, India, has never managed to host one — two days after Washington publicly rejected a report that the grouping was on life support as fake news.
The Story — The leaders of India, the United States, Japan and Australia are expected to meet in Manila on Tuesday evening, November 17, for the first Quad leaders’ summit since September 2024 — and the first ever held in a country that is not a member of the grouping. Sources in New Delhi confirmed the plan to The Hindu on Saturday, November 14: Prime Minister Narendra Modi will sit down with US President Donald Trump, Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi and Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese on the sidelines of the ASEAN summits, probably after Mr Trump lands in Manila. Japan had confirmed on Friday that arrangements were being made, and US officials briefing in Washington confirmed Mr Trump will take part in a “multilateral meeting” with the Quad leaders. India has not formally announced the meeting: on Friday the MEA’s spokesperson, Randhir Jaiswal, said only that the Ministry would “keep [them] updated,” and officials who confirmed the summit on Saturday evening were still awaiting formal intimation of its timing. Mr Modi is in Manila from November 16 to 18 for the ASEAN-India Summit and the East Asia Summit.
The expected agenda, per officials briefed on the preparations, is critical-mineral supply chains, securing commercial shipping lanes for energy supplies, and attacks on commercial ships — a live issue for India, at least 30 of whose seafarers have been killed in attacks in the Hormuz Strait, the Sea of Oman and the Black Sea; a Quad Business Forum mechanism may also be announced. India chairs the grouping and was to host the summit in 2025; it never happened, mainly, The Hindu’s sources say, due to the US President’s unavailability, and New Delhi is unwilling to hand over the chairship without hosting — which may yet happen in Delhi next year.
On November 14, Politico reported that the Trump administration’s approach had left the grouping “on life support.” On Sunday, November 15, US Assistant Secretary of State Dylan Johnson rebutted the report on X as an “utterly ridiculous take” and “Fake News,” citing five meetings between Secretary of State Marco Rubio and the Quad foreign ministers in two years — three of them in the past six months — and monthly sherpa calls. Much of the attention may in any case be taken by Mr Trump’s next stop: Shenzhen on November 19, for the first-ever three-way summit with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin, on global issues including nuclear arms control.
The Hindu’s report (November 15, by Suhasini Haidar) is built on unnamed New Delhi sources, and even its headline hedges — the summit is only “likely.” Its spine is not the agenda but the chair’s predicament: the Manila meeting, the paper writes, “indicates the challenges that India has faced as the Chair” of a grouping it has been unable to host even once since the leader-level upgrade in 2021, “mainly due to the U.S. President’s unavailability,” with New Delhi unwilling to hand over the chairship without hosting. The MEA’s refusal to confirm on the record, and the officials still awaiting formal intimation on Saturday evening, are carried high, and the report closes by noting that Mr Trump’s Shenzhen trilateral will take much of the attention. The agenda is present, but as reported expectation from unnamed officials, not as promise.
ANI’s Sunday report (November 15) leads not with the summit plan but with Washington’s public defence of the grouping: the State Department’s rebuttal of Politico’s “on life support” report is the headline and the lead, with the Manila meeting appearing inside it as a summit the US is “working to formalize.” Secretary (East) Rudrendra Tandon’s refusal to confirm a Modi–Trump meeting or a Quad session is carried mid-story, and the wire then fills out India’s wider Manila programme — Act East, the ASEAN trade-agreement review, BrahMos sales to the Philippines, Myanmar — in programme order. Claim, counter-claim and itinerary: the wire reports a defence mounted, not a verdict on the grouping’s health.
Times Now World, reporting Secretary Rubio’s announcement of the Manila summit (October 31), presents the meeting as momentum restored. Its section head is “Strengthening Diplomatic Ties and Regional Cooperation”; the summit is “a significant opportunity to re-establish high-level political momentum” and a platform to “solidify their strategic alignment,” following three Quad foreign ministers’ meetings this year in New Delhi, Manila and Atlanta. India’s failure to host the 2025 summit it was due is rendered in one clause — “scheduling challenges and uncertainty regarding travel arrangements” — and no question about the grouping’s health arises: on this side the Quad was never dying, it was coordinating, and Manila is the forward march made visible.
The issue — The Quad’s first leaders’ meeting in over two years is happening on borrowed ground because its chair could not host it, and it arrives preceded by a public argument about whether the grouping is dying at all; what the four leaders produce on minerals and shipping will matter more than the photograph.
What to watch — Whether Tuesday evening produces a joint statement with concrete deliverables — the Business Forum, shipping and minerals initiatives — or only a photograph; whether Delhi finally gets its hosting turn next year; and whether Mr Trump’s Shenzhen trilateral with Xi and Putin two days later swallows the Manila story whole.
Related Stories, Three Angles
Rahul Gandhi Said India Is No Longer a Democracy — the BJP Says He Asked Foreigners to Remove Modi
At the Bharat Summit’s closing session in Hyderabad on Saturday, the Leader of the Opposition declared that Indian democracy was destroyed in 2014 and questioned the legitimacy of the 2024 election — by Sunday, the BJP was calling him a puppet of foreign powers who had begged foreign delegates to remove the Modi government.
Read More →129 Websites Were Blocked on Two Court Orders That Never Existed — Now the PMO Wants an Explanation
The telecom department ordered internet providers to block 129 betting websites this year on two High Court orders that both courts say were never issued — and on Saturday the Prime Minister’s Office summoned the telecom secretary to explain how it happened.
Read More →