DELHI PRESS
Show Some Respect to These Books — the Supreme Court Halts the Shifting of a 135-Year-Old Library
The Central Secretariat Library — founded in 1891, holding 8.5 lakh books, some dating to 1702 — must move out of Shastri Bhawan for the Central Vista demolition. On Monday the Supreme Court stopped the shift, called the Centre’s approach ad hoc, and asked why a heritage collection was offered two rooms of 300 square metres against the 5,466 it needs.
The Story — The Central Secretariat Library (CSL), founded in Calcutta in 1891 as the Imperial Secretariat Library, moved to Delhi in 1911 and has been housed at Shastri Bhawan since 1969. It holds more than 8.5 lakh volumes — rare books, government publications, official records and gazetteers, some dating to 1702 — across about 5,500 square metres on four floors, and is the second-largest Central government library after the National Library in Kolkata. Shastri Bhawan is slated for demolition under the Central Vista redevelopment, so the library must move; the dispute is over where, and how carefully.
The Culture Ministry sought about 5,466 square metres for the library in the redeveloped secretariat; the Directorate of Estates proposed two rooms measuring around 300 square metres at Kartavya Bhawan-2, and the Culture Ministry told the Housing Ministry in February that the proposed space was inadequate and that relocating the entire library there was not feasible. The Supreme Court took suo motu cognisance in October, following an Indian Express report titled “135-yr-old library, 8.5 lakh books – and no room in the new Central Vista plan,” and sought a detailed affidavit with layout plans — including whether the proposed space could also hold some two lakh books kept at a facility in RK Puram.
On Monday, November 16, a bench of Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva heard the matter. Amicus curiae Haripriya Padmanabhan said the authorities showed urgency to shift the books by November, sought clarity on the space at the proposed new location, and reported that books at RK Puram — lying there for nearly 15 years — were in “atrocious” condition. Justice Kumar asked what the hurry was: “There seems to be an ad hoc approach… this is practically a heritage for us, dating back to 1702. If you don’t want them, give it to some other country that will value them,” and added, “Show some respect to these books, two lakh books thrown to the wind.” Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati submitted that the RK Puram books came from the Tulsi Sadan Library, the CSL’s Hindi and regional-language wing; the bench asked the amicus to verify whether they carry the library’s identification tags. The Court recorded the ASG’s statement that the books will not be shifted until the next hearing, listed the matter for November 20, and directed that the Centre’s affidavit filed that day be placed on record.
The Hindu’s headline puts the confrontation first and the outcome second: the Centre is “pulled up,” the shifting halted. The framing is institutional — a government rebuked by the court over its own heritage collection — and the paper’s report is tagged “critical” of the Centre in the multi-outlet roundup where it was read. The heritage stakes sit inside a governance-failure frame: haste, inadequate space, and a court forced to intervene in a suo motu case that press reporting itself triggered.
ANI’s wire carries the whole file in sequence and at length: the amicus’s urgency and RK Puram submissions, the bench’s remarks quoted in full, the ASG’s Tulsi Sadan answer and the tag-verification direction, and the operative order — “ASG says the books will not be shifted until next hearing. List on 20th November.” It then supplies the background the other sides carry only in part: the October notice, the 5,466-square-metre ask against the 300-square-metre offer, and the Culture Ministry’s February letter saying a full shift was not feasible. Claim, counter-claim and the paper trail, with no verdict of its own.
Mirror Now’s report (November 17) also leads with the rebuke — the Court “intervened,” a “sharp rebuke,” books in “atrocious conditions” — but its second half is given to the government’s account under a “Future of the Central Secretariat Library” head: the ASG’s clarification that the RK Puram books are Tulsi Sadan stock stored there for years, the approximately 5,583 square metres earmarked to house both libraries permanently, and the point that Tulsi Sadan had closed for metro station construction and is merely undergoing a temporary relocation. The space dispute’s numbers — 300 square metres offered against 5,466 sought — and the Culture Ministry’s infeasibility letter do not appear. On this side, the story is a heritage scare with a plan behind it, not a ministry left without room.
The issue — No book moves before November 20, and the Centre must now put its affidavit — space, layout and preservation plan — on record for a collection it was ready to shift on a 300-square-metre offer against a documented need for more than 5,000.
What to watch — The November 20 hearing; whether the amicus’s tag check confirms the RK Puram stock is the library’s own; and whether the permanent home officials cite is documented in the affidavit or remains an assurance.
Related Stories, Three Angles
Hasina Vows to Come Home in December Despite the Death Sentence — Dhaka Says She Returns Extradited or Not at All
Sheikh Hasina, in hiding in India since 2024 and sentenced to death in her absence, told AFP on Monday she will return to Bangladesh in December even if it kills her — hours after Dhaka repeated that she will be brought back only as an extradited prisoner, and as her supporters fought police in her hometown demanding her return.
Read More →Two Years Late, the Quad Meets Tuesday on Borrowed Ground — Washington Says It Was Never on Life Support
The Quad’s leaders will meet in Manila on Tuesday evening for their first summit since 2024 — in a country that is not a member, because the chair, India, has never managed to host one — two days after Washington publicly rejected a report that the grouping was on life support as fake news.
Read More →